Thomson TDW4510SL2 or Asko DFS344ID.S: which should you choose?
Comparison of the two dishwashers using our catalogue's scoring criteria, value by value. Scores are relative to all the models we have analysed.
Thomson TDW4510SL2
Main drawbackLimited capacity for serving dishes alongside plates after larger gatherings
Read the full analysis →
Asko DFS344ID.S
Main drawbackAverage Eco electricity consumption is the main drawback
Read the full analysis →Our verdict based on your priority
Across all criteria, Asko DFS344ID.S scores higher (8.6 vs 7.9 out of 10).
- Priority: “Place settings”Asko DFS344ID.S 8.2 / 10 vs 6.8
- Priority: “Noise level”Asko DFS344ID.S 8.5 / 10 vs 7.5
- Priority: “Eco program duration”Asko DFS344ID.S 9.3 / 10 vs 8.8
- Priority: “Number of programs”Asko DFS344ID.S 9.1 / 10 vs 7.2
By criterion
| Criterion | Thomson TDW4510SL2 | Asko DFS344ID.S |
|---|---|---|
| Place settings | 6.8 | 8.2 advantage |
| Noise level | 7.5 | 8.5 advantage |
| Eco program electricity consumption | 8.2 | 8 |
| Eco program water consumption | 8.9 | 8.5 |
| Eco program duration | 8.8 | 9.3 advantage |
| Number of programs | 7.2 | 9.1 advantage |
A gap of less than half a point does not count as an advantage: our scores are relative to the catalogue, and using them to pick a winner would imply a level of precision we cannot offer.
Side-by-side specs
| Specification | Thomson TDW4510SL2 | Asko DFS344ID.S |
|---|---|---|
| Width | 45 cm | 60 cm |
| Height | 85 cm | Not provided |
| Depth | 60 cm | 59,6 cm |
| Place settings | 10 place settings | 14 place settings |
| Noise level | 44 dB | 42 dB |
| Eco program electricity consumption | 67,4 kWh/100 cycles | 74 kWh/100 cycles |
| Eco program water consumption | 9 L/cycle | 9,2 L/cycle |
| Eco program duration | 215 min | 195 min |
| Number of programs | 6 programs | 9 programs |
| Installation type | Freestanding | Freestanding |
| Energy class | D | C |
| Use | Domestic | Domestic |
| End of cycle | Automatic door opening | Automatic door opening |
| Basket layout | Height-adjustable upper basket | Height-adjustable upper basket |
| Wash programs | Hygiene | Eco |
| Wash options | Half load | Program duration reduction |
| Drying technology | Automatic door opening | Automatic door opening |
Figures published by manufacturers and retailers, compiled in our reviews. “Not provided” means the figure could not be verified.
Which is right for you?
Thomson TDW4510SL2
Leads on 0 criterion of 6 compared
- No numerical specification sets it apart in this comparison.
Asko DFS344ID.S
Leads on 4 criteria of 6 compared
- Number of programs: 9.1/10 vs 7.2/10 (9 programs vs 6 programs)
- Place settings: 8.2/10 vs 6.8/10 (14 place settings vs 10 place settings)
- Noise level: 8.5/10 vs 7.5/10 (42 dB vs 44 dB)
- Eco program duration: 9.3/10 vs 8.8/10 (195 min vs 215 min)
Comparison based on published specifications and our scores, calculated using the same criteria for every model. Our methodology →
Frequently asked questions
Which is rated higher, Thomson TDW4510SL2 or Asko DFS344ID.S?
Asko DFS344ID.S scores 8.6/10, compared with 7.9/10 for Thomson TDW4510SL2, using the same scoring criteria.
Which wins on “Number of programs”?
Asko DFS344ID.S wins on “Number of programs”: 9.1/10 compared with 7.2/10 for Thomson TDW4510SL2. Recorded values: 9 programs versus 6 programs.
Which wins on “Place settings”?
Asko DFS344ID.S wins on “Place settings”: 8.2/10 compared with 6.8/10 for Thomson TDW4510SL2. Recorded values: 14 place settings versus 10 place settings.
Which wins on “Noise level”?
Asko DFS344ID.S wins on “Noise level”: 8.5/10 compared with 7.5/10 for Thomson TDW4510SL2. Recorded values: 42 dB versus 44 dB.
Which wins on “Eco program duration”?
Asko DFS344ID.S wins on “Eco program duration”: 9.3/10 compared with 8.8/10 for Thomson TDW4510SL2. Recorded values: 195 min versus 215 min.